Only Original Parties Misstatement
This trap appears as a wrong-answer choice in 1 active question. Spotting how it is built is the repair: read each example's “why it's attractive” before the “why it's wrong.”
Subject distribution
- Civil Procedure1
Example wrong choices
17711_mercy_clinic_zoning · CIVIL_PROCEDURE · Choice BIntervention is required because zoning decisions affect the public.
Why it's attractive
The student hears 'zoning' and 'public' and assumes intervention is mandatory. The Silver Key tells them the public importance of zoning is not a magic override of Rule 24's timeliness requirement.
Why it's wrong
The student hears 'zoning' and 'public' and assumes intervention is mandatory. The Silver Key tells them the public importance of zoning is not a magic override of Rule 24's timeliness requirement.
17711_mercy_clinic_zoning · CIVIL_PROCEDURE · Choice CIntervention must be denied because only original parties may raise traffic-impact arguments.
Why it's attractive
Rule 24 expressly allows non-parties to raise arguments; the question is whether the Rule 24 requirements are met, not whether the movant is a named party.
Why it's wrong
Rule 24 expressly allows non-parties to raise arguments; the question is whether the Rule 24 requirements are met, not whether the movant is a named party.
17711_mercy_clinic_zoning · CIVIL_PROCEDURE · Choice DMary's Mercy has no possible interest because it is not a property owner.
Why it's attractive
Rule 24(a)(2) requires an interest that may be impaired by the disposition; it does not require property ownership. A mobile-medical ministry that operates clinics in the affected neighborhood has a cognizable interest in traffic, parking, and patient access.
Why it's wrong
Rule 24(a)(2) requires an interest that may be impaired by the disposition; it does not require property ownership. A mobile-medical ministry that operates clinics in the affected neighborhood has a cognizable interest in traffic, parking, and patient access.
Practice the questions that use this trap as a distractor and get full Wrong Answer Forensics on submit.
Practice questions using this trap →