EVIDENCE-PILOT-0131010407OUTLINE NODE
REFRESH RECOLLECTION VERSUS RECORDED RECOLLECTION

Refreshing recollection

Refreshing recollection uses a prompt to revive memory; recorded recollection substitutes a record when memory stays weak.

▌ Linked Questions + Keys

Case studies

5

Reusable keys

15

Trap keys

5

LeadMe steps

35

Drill seeds

15

Q14825 / key C

Refreshing Recollection: Before vs. During

selected 31010407 / source 31010407

Open case study ->

Q17318 / key B

Refreshing Recollection: On-Stand Access

selected 31010407 / source 31010407

Open case study ->

Q18076 / key D

Refreshing Recollection: Any Material Can Jog Memory

selected 31010407 / source 31010407

Open case study ->

Q22211 / key C

Business Records vs. Past Recollection Recorded

selected 31010407 / source 31010407

Open case study ->

Q22227 / key C

Refreshing Recollection: Pretrial Notes Inspection

selected 31010407 / source 31010407

Open case study ->
▌ Key Samples + Proof Drills

Gold Key / Q14825

GK-EVIDENCE-612-REFRESH-TIMING-01

Under Rule 612, a writing used while testifying must be produced to the adverse party; a writing used before testifying may be produced if justice requires.

Silver Key / Q14825

SK-EVIDENCE-REFRESH-NOT-RECORDED-RECOLLECTION

Do not import recorded-recollection foundation into refreshing recollection; authorship and read-and-approved status are not the Rule 612 trigger.

Trap Key / Q14825

TK-EVIDENCE-REFRESH-ONLY-ON-STAND

The on-stand rule is mandatory, but it is not exclusive; pre-testimony refresh remains discretionary.

Gold Key / Q17318

GK-EVIDENCE-612-ON-STAND-PRODUCTION-01

A writing used to refresh memory while the witness is testifying must be produced for adverse-party inspection and related cross-examination.

Proof drill / Q14825

Before vs. During

A witness reviews a third-party report the night before trial to refresh memory. What is the court's inspection rule for the adverse party?

The court may allow inspection if justice requires.

Proof drill / Q17318

Not Offered

A witness uses a note on the stand to refresh memory, but the proponent never offers the note. Can the adverse party inspect it?

Yes. Use while testifying triggers Rule 612 inspection rights.

▌ Atlas Node
NODE PATH

01 Presentation of Evidence

02 Witnesses

03 Refreshing recollection

TRAP KEY SEED

What this page must catch

Reading the writing into evidence just because it refreshed the witness.

▌ Required Question Row Locks

source_outline_code

recommended_outline_code

recode_status

recode_reason

red_axis

purple_array_profile

blue_by_choice

leadme_next_step